Review | 'Tiger Lily'

Tiger Lily by Jodi Lynn Anderson
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

This book was fantastic. But it was so, so depressing.

Just a disclaimer, this review WILL contain spoilers pertaining to the book, but I really don't want to hide the WHOLE review because of spoilers, because I just--I just--blech. No. Enjoy, and beware of spoilers!

I used to absolutely love the relationship between Wendy Darling and Peter Pan, but this book totally changed my outlook on the whole ordeal, and made me become so interested in the character of Tiger Lily, a character who--prior to reading this book--I'd never put much stock into. From the moment the relationship between Tiger Lily and Peter Pan was built, I knew there would be all these FEELS.

Okay, so let's analyze/examine some pros and cons from the story.

CONS:
>The beginning is a VERY slow start. I "started" the book in October, read the first chapter, and didn't pick it up again until November. I definitely think the author could have done a better job at catching the reader's attention. But once you get to Tiger Lily's first confrontation with Peter, things start to pick up a bit.

PROS:
>At first, I was going to put this as a con, but then I reconsidered. The amount of time we spend with Wendy is satisfactorily short. I was initially surprised at how late she entered the story, and how short her stay was, but looking back, I think it's a good thing. It provides this sense of realistic heartbreak for Tiger Lily; this English girl slipping in, attracting the likes of Peter and the lost boys, and then essentially ripping him right out of her life.

>Tiger Lily's character. Oh my gosh, Tiger Lily was fantastic. I love how quiet yet strong she is. She's got this brutality and innocence to her that is often hard to portray in YA fiction, but Jodi Lynn Anderson does a fantastic job of illustrating it in this book. I really loved Tiger Lily, and rooted for her the entire book through. My heart broke when hers did, which is a sign of a fantastic character.

>Tinker Bell's narration. I went into this book thinking that it would be narrated from Tiger Lily's perspective, but I was proven wrong right off the bat. At first, I didn't know how I would react to Tinker Bell creepily following Tiger Lily and Peter around, but I grew to like--and appreciate--it. She definitely provides this objective, unbiased, yet sensitive, look into their relationship. I love how she confesses to falling in love with Peter, and admitting to nothing ever happening between the two of them. I love her commentary on every person; her contempt for Wendy, and her eventual disappointment towards Tiger Lily's character change, especially.

>Peter's letter to Tiger Lily. This was just so--ugh. This letter seriously made me say, "THEN WHY THE HELL DIDN'T YOU STAY WITH TIGER LILY, YOU DOUCHE?" The letter made sense, though, and it provided some more sadness to Tinker Bell's visit to England and running into an aged version of Peter Pan (which was so depressing).

>The realism. Especially for a book of such crazy scenarios, Tiger Lily hits home in a way most YA fantasies don't do. So many authors could take a hint from Anderson.

Overall, Tiger Lily has a fantastic plot with groundbreaking characters, and I definitely recommend it to anyone and everyone.

View all my reviews